Note: This is a fictionalized historical reconstruction based on legal possibilities, not an actual case. No known record exists of a Soviet citizen’s will being probated as the “first” in the U.S.; this piece imagines how such a precedent might have unfolded.
“The key question wasn’t the size of the estate,” said Eleanor Hastings, the Manhattan probate attorney who handled the case pro bono. “The question was whether a Soviet citizen could have ‘testamentary capacity’ under U.S. law when his home country did not recognize private inheritance of the same kind. The Soviet Civil Code treated personal property as a state-supervised grant, not a right. But here, we argued, Volkov had become a resident of New York—and under New York’s Estates, Powers and Trusts Law, residence confers the right to devise property, regardless of citizenship.” “The question was whether a Soviet citizen could
The court agreed. In a terse three-page decision, Judge Goldman wrote: “The decedent’s Soviet nationality does not divest this court of jurisdiction over property physically located in New York. His will is self-proving under EPTL 3-2.1. Therefore, probate is granted.” But here, we argued, Volkov had become a